Modern Election Arguments Against The Electoral College

Brendon Goss Ms. Houle English 9-8 11 April 2017 The Modern Election-Arguments Against the Electoral College The electoral college is a mash-up of ancient ideas that amalgamate in an outdated mess that doesn t make sense in the modern day. In the 2000 US election, George W. Bush won the electoral college and lost the popular vote, This proved that the electoral college has too much power in comparison to the popular vote and disproved what the founding fathers had planned for the college included all peoples having equal representation. The founding fathers had planned the electoral college as a compromise between the people and congress choosing the president. With modern day technologies, this system from the as become obsolete. The†¦show more content†¦The electoral college has not changed since its conception in the first congressional convention in 1836. Even then, many of the pre-existing things are vague and cryptic such as in the constitution the electoral college is only referenced once in article II. Article II-1 of the U.S. Constitution states â€Å"The executive Powe r shall be vested in a President of the United States of America. He shall hold his Office during the Term of four Years, and, together with the Vice- President, chosen for the same Term, be elected, as follows each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in the Congress: but no Senator or Representative, or Person holding an Office of Trust or Profit under the United States, shall be appointed an Elector.†(Presidental Election Laws, ). As this reading states briefly that the number of electors is dictated by a legislator and the legislator bases the number of electors on the population. These things should be fixed in order to better represent all states equally within the electoral college. Arguments Against the Electoral College The four major arguments against the Electoral CollegeShow MoreRelatedThe Electoral College : Ingenious Or Inept? Essay1506 Words   |  7 PagesThe Electoral College: Ingenious or Inept? The 2016 presidential election left many voters feeling bitter and hostile. President-elect Donald Trump is a minority president, meaning that he won the electoral vote yet lost the popular vote (â€Å"2016 Election Results†). There have only been four minority presidents preceding Trump: John Quincy Adams, Rutherford B. Hayes, Benjamin Harrison, and George W. Bush (Stepman). However, recently some voters and politicians began calling for eliminating the electoralRead MoreThe Electoral College System Essay1495 Words   |  6 PagesIn the Electoral College system, as presented by Hamilton, every voice is heard and there is a greater guarantee that the elected will effectively represents those voices in office. During election season, the people in the states vote for the representatives that will make up the Electoral College. The people within the states will votes for the prudent few that they believe best conform to their political interests, just as they do for those vot ed into the House of Representatives. As a resultRead MoreAnalysis Of Federalist 10 By James Madison1525 Words   |  7 PagesMadison, he addresses key issues like factions and democracy, all while focusing on the usefulness of the Constitution and the necessity of a strong central government, to defend his Federalist ideology. Personally, I agree with the foundation of his arguments, especially on the topic of forms of government, as well as the role of representation in our government. Madison’s primary focus throughout the beginning of this paper is factions. He holds a deep disdain for them as he thinks that they solely focusRead MoreFederalists Vs. Anti Federalists1518 Words   |  7 Pagesincompatible. In fact, a â€Å"filtered mirror† that merges the two theories together in a system that is both inclusive and deliberative, would better serve the interest of the public and government at large. The Anti-Federalists raised several well founded arguments for a state referendum, in which every eligible voter could voice his opinions on policy choices. To these statesmen, mass participation served â€Å"as a proxy for actual consent† and the only way â€Å"in which the true Sentiments of the people could beRead MorePresidential Election : The Presidential Electoral College, Civic Engagement, And Campaign Strategies Essay1941 Words   |  8 Pagesof the 2016 Presidential Election stunned the world. But were these results really all that surprising? America was prepared for a change in policy and election projections were incorrect due to the fact that there existed many â€Å"under cover Trumpers†, whom voted their conscience but were not willing to openly admit their political beliefs for fear of condemnation. The 2016 Presidential Election results open many areas for research into the legitimacy of the Electoral College, civic engagement, andRead MoreMidterm . Section One: . Shay’S Rebellion: An Uprising1811 Words   |  8 Pageshas the power, a hereditary one, holds political power. The fear of monarchy is what led the Founding Fathers to devise a plan to divide the power amongst the government. Electorate: Citizens entitled to vote in an election. This term has a strong significance towards elections because we get to vote for whom we think should represent our country. Enumerated Powers: Powers granted to congress under a specific Article in the Constitution. These powers include the right to tax and provide nationalRead More Electoral College Reform Essay2402 Words   |  10 PagesIn order to fully understand the underlying problems of the Electoral College we have to look back at the time that the idea of the Electoral College itself was proposed and see how the culture of the time and the ideologies of the people involved helped shaped the final outcome. Life today is much different than it was two hundred odd something years ago, and it’s fair to say that the political ideals and social norms around our society have changed drastically. When the founding fathers sat downRead MoreEssay on John Adams1466 Words   |  6 Pagesthe early formation of the new federal power (Ferling, 1992). Adams was a well educated, seasoned patriot, and experienced diplomat. He was the runner-up in the election in which George Washington was selected the first United States President. According to the electoral-college system of that time, the second candidate with the most electoral votes became the Vice President (Smelser amp; Gundersen, 1975). As president, Washington appointed, among others, two influential political leaders to his originalRead More Government and Politics - We Need Election Reform in America1754 Words   |  8 Pagesperhaps both. -- James Madison (Focus 1) The United States has strived to be a true democracy, a place in which the citizens are free to govern themselves, since its inception. For a democracy to work, the citizens must remain knowledgeable and elections must remain unbiased. Our current system of electing presidents fails in both of these regards: citizens are only given two choices that stand any chance of winning and their decisions between those two candidates are influenced not by knowledgeRead MorePresidential Election Of Modern America Essay2251 Words   |  10 PagesPresidential elections in modern America are incredibly complex and multi-faceted, and have only grown more intricate as time progresses. First, a candidate must win the nomination of his or her party through a series of state primaries or caucuses. To do this, the candidate must appeal specifically to his or her party demographic, and is more concerned with the inter-party competition than the competition from the other party. Once the nomination is fo rmally awarded to a candidate at the respective